Court Overrules Previous Judgment that Behemoth Frontman was Expressing Artistic Freedom of Tearing up Bible
Adam “Nergal” Darski, frontman for Behemoth, faces a second trial on charges he insulted religious sentiment when he called the Catholic Church “the most murderous cult on the planet” during the band’s September 2007 performance in Gdynia and tore up a copy of the Bible, calling it “a book of lies.”
A district court in Gdansk Tuesday overruled an earlier judgment that Darski was expressing artistic freedom during the concert.
Video footage of today’s ruling can be seen below.
The European Commission last fall said that Poland’s prosecution of Darski for “blasphemy” is against European values.
In a statement released last October, it said that “national blasphemy laws are a matter for the domestic legal order of the member states.”
It cited the European Convention Of Human Rights, a Poland-signatory treaty attached to the Strasbourg-based rights watchdog, the Council of Europe, on freedom of expression.
“This right protects not only information or ideas that are favorably received or regarded as inoffensive or as a matter of indifference, but also those that offend, shock or disturb,” the commission said.
Back in August 2011, a Polish judge ruled that Darski’s ripping up of a Bible during a show was a form of artistic expression consistent with the style of his band.
Judge Krzysztof Wieckowski said he considered Darski’s actions “a form of art.” He added that the court had no intention of limiting freedom of expression or the right to criticize religion.
The court said audience members who testified said their religious feelings had not been hurt despite the fact they were Christians.
The crime carries a maximum sentence of two years in jail.
After the 2007 incident, Nowak sued Behemoth for promoting Satanism. Although a court expert witness on religious matters said that the act of destroying the Holy Bible could offend somebody’s religious feelings, the case was discontinued because no one except Ryszard Nowak, chairman of the privately run Nationwide Defence Committee Against Sects, accused Behemoth of insulting their religious beliefs. (Under Polish law, there must be at least two formal complaints before a charge is laid. The previous complaint was made in 2008, and recently an unspecified number of other complaints had been filed.)
In a 2009 interview with Decibel magazine, Behemoth bassist Tomasz “Orion” Wróblewski explained that the Bible-tearing incident was by no means a spontaneous outburst. “We’d been doing that for two years on tour before it happened in Poland,” he said. “So, we had discussed it many times before. A Behemoth show is a Behemoth show, and Behemoth fans are coming to a Behemoth show. Behemoth fans know what Behemoth is about, know what the lyrics are about, and know at least a little of the philosophy behind the band. So, it’s kind of surprising that there are people coming to the shows and feeling offended with what we do onstage. If such a person comes to a show, he comes with the purpose of being offended, I guess, and it shouldn’t be like that. We’re not offending any particular person. We’re just offending the religion that we’ve been raised in.”
Behemoth’s Adam “Nergal” Darski tearing up the Bible: